One
of the most difficult questions to answer concerns the way prayer for the
well-being of another often appears unanswered. A spouse might pray that their
partner doesn’t die or a parent that their child be healed – after all, didn’t Jesus
say: ‘I will do anything you ask in my name.’ (John 14.13). But the fact is
that many do not find that Jesus does what they ask in prayers they offer. This
is something people have grappled with for a long time and in The Mystery of
Faith I gave some attention to that question in a number of places, including
writing this in Chapter 11 (p.90):
‘Asking
for something on behalf of another might be a natural response to a deeply felt
need – ‘Oh God, let Mary get better!’ But if we’re going to ask someone for
something, it’s best to be in a relationship with them. And when we bring our
desires (supplications) to God, we need to trust that God will respond to them in
the right way. Our heart might be overflowing with concerns, but we need to let
go of them to God otherwise they can become overwhelming:
‘Thy will be
done
on earth as it is in heaven.’
Intercession
isn’t about getting God to do what we want (no matter how good our intentions);
it’s learning to open our hearts to God’s compassionate love, offering our
concerns to Christ (because it’s he who prays for us) and then trusting him.’
* * *
Many
Christians have been led to believe that prayer concerns this matter of asking
for things but were never taught of the importance of the context in which
intercession is offered – without a context, intercession would seem little
more than a ‘penny-in-the-slot’ affair: you offer the prayer and get what you ask
for. But, if they thought about it, I imagine few would accept that understanding.
If every prayer ‘in Jesus’ name’ were answered exactly as offered there’d be
chaos! John might pray for a rainy day and Jill for a dry one; Pedro for
Barcelona to win and Johannes for Berlin; Yuri might even pray for success in
robbing a bank! But what about that prayer which is offered for the healing of
a loved one? Surely, if there is a loving God such a request would be granted?
Again, to quote from The Mystery (Chapter 6, p.51):
‘What
to make of suffering
But
if God is good why should there be suffering? Couldn’t God have created a world
where people didn’t hurt each other, where Nature was kindly? The scriptures,
especially the psalms, reveal ways in which people have grappled with
suffering, even blaming, but always in dialogue with, God (e.g. 22). The Book
of Job grapples with this: there you’ll find lament, complaint, accusation –
but trust that God will not, in the end, abandon Job utterly. We touched on
that in Ch.2, recognising that suffering is part of the mystery of life and can
reveal depths of compassion we might not otherwise experience. …
Our
forebears, wanting to help us connect our suffering with his, and to show just
how much Christ suffered, often showed his wounds in graphic detail. You may
have seen the famous 16th century Isenheim Altarpiece by Matthias Grünewald
which the monks, who cared for victims of plague, placed in their hospital. I
remember being deeply moved on kneeling before an ancient statue of the dead
Christ and noticing how his body showed the signs of beating, blood pouring
from wounds in his head, hands and feet, and knew that all pain and suffering
was to be found here. …
What
did God experience as Jesus hung there? God-in-Christ must have known immense suffering
in order to fully share in this world-changing moment. Apart from the physical,
emotional and spiritual suffering he saw the love of friends and the anguish of
his mother – such deep anguish that only a mother can have for her child. He
saw the absence of insight in some, the superficiality of others and lack of
interest in the onlookers. He saw it all, and more – he saw the depth of his
own Heart. Fear was there yet, beneath that and stronger than that, he saw
love, love now darkly crowned. And, for one brief moment, he cried in the words
of Psalm 22, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (Matthew 27.46) … ‘
* *
*
Of
course, some will say – ‘but if God is good, why didn’t he make a world without
suffering?’ Others, as I wrote: ‘seeing so much injustice, pain and suffering, (will)
decide that if God does exist then ‘he’ must be very evil to have created such
monstrous things. But recognising such complexity Christianity knows that
‘evil’ must co-exist with ‘good’; what appear to be random, sometimes chaotic
processes are indispensable if we’re to have the universe we know (and we can’t
know any other). If things had been even slightly different, life probably couldn’t
have emerged from primordial chaos.’ (Chapter 2, p.15)
It’s
a sad fact that, without suffering we would never know the depths of compassion
of which the heart is capable, never know what love is able to express –
Christianity alone holds this paradox of life and suffering being intrinsically
entwined, which is why the Crucified is central to our faith. The question,
‘why doesn’t God heal the one I love’ has no other answer apart from the image
of the Crucified; again, to quote from The Mystery of Faith: ‘Here is our
God-made-Man hanging on the Cross. Not an all-mighty, ever-powerful Lord but
someone naked and vulnerable. That is the uniqueness of our faith – the God in
whom we believe, the maker of heaven and earth, who was prepared to know what
it is to be human, to be weak, frightened and lonely, just as you and I can be.
That’s why people have been drawn to and by this moment. It’s what’s inspired
great artists, writers, musicians and poets who identify with Jesus hanging,
dying, on the cross’ (Ch. 6, p.58).
Living
in a culture where we expect pain and suffering to be cured and where pills and
treatments can suppressor even eradicate pain, it’s almost inevitable that we
feel suffering, especially ‘innocent’ suffering, doesn’t belong in life. Many
expect God to act like the ultimate doctor – but, reading the bible, that’s
never been the view of people of faith. When people are taught about intercession
it needs to be set in the context of trusting in the ultimate purposes of a God
who seeks the good of all Creation. ‘Thy kingdom come; thy will be done’ needs
to be the context in which our intercessions are offered. So, long before
teaching about this matter of praying-for-healing, we need to understand and
believe that God, who suffered and died for us, continues to suffer with us and
is leading us to at-one-ness with Him. The Sacred Heart of Christ still bleeds
for us but would also enfold us in His mercy and compassion. As a recent
theologian has said:
‘To
ask for something in Jesus’ name does not mean that we invoke him verbally and
then desire
whatever our turbulent, divided heart or our appetite, our wretched
mania for everything and anything, happens to hanker for. No, asking in Jesus’
name means entering into him, living by him, being one with him in love and
faith. If he is in us by faith, in love, in grace, in his Spirit, then our
petition arises from the centre of our being, which is himself, and if all our
petition and desire is gathered up and fused in him and his Spirit, then the
Father hears us. Then our petition becomes simple and straightforward,
harmonious, sober, and unpretentious.
'Then
what St. Paul says in the letter to the Romans applies to us: we do not know
how to pray as we ought, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us, praying the
one prayer, “Abba! Father”! He longs for that from which the Spirit and Jesus
himself have proceeded: he longs for God, he asks God for God, on our behalf he
asks of God. Everything is included and contained in this prayer. … [If we pray
in this way] we shall see that God really answers our prayer, in one way or
another. Then we shall no longer feel this “one way or the other” is a feeble
excuse offered by the pious, and the gospel, for unanswered prayer.
'No.
Our prayer is answered, but precisely because it is prayer in Jesus’ name; and
what we ultimately pray for is for the Lord to grow in our lives, to fill our
existence with himself, to triumph, to gather into one our scattered life, the
thousand and one desires of which we are made. … To pray in Jesus’ name is to
have one’s prayer answered, to receive God and God’s blessing, and then, even
amid tears, even in pain, even in indigence, even when it seems that one has
still not been heard, the heart rests in God, and that is—while we are still
here on pilgrimage, far from the Lord—perfect joy.' (Fr. Karl Rahner SJ)